Charcuterie board with a jar of Penna Pickled Garlic
Penna Blog

6 Gift Basket Ideas You Can Build Around a Jar of Olives (Plus 3 White Elephant Picks)

By Penna Olives3 min read

A gift basket does not have to come from a catalog. Pick a theme, put three or four jars in a bag or a bowl, and tie a ribbon on it. The theme is what makes it feel like you thought about it.

Here are six baskets built around our jars, with the real total for each, then three picks for white elephant.

Charcuterie board with a jar of Penna Pickled Garlic

1. The cheese board basket, $28.70

Tapenade, Muffaletta Spread and Blue Cheese Stuffed Olives. Add a box of crackers and a small wedge of cheese if you want to go further. Tapenade contains anchovies and the olives contain dairy.

Penna Tapenade jarPenna Muffaletta Spread jarPenna Blue Cheese Stuffed Olives jar

2. The martini night basket, from $36.60

Dirty Martini Mix, Vodkatini Olives, Blue Cheese Stuffed Olives and Cocktail Onions. Add a shaker or two glasses. We wrote a full guide to this one: The Dirty Martini Lover Gift Guide.

Penna Dirty Martini Mix bottlePenna Vodkatini Olives jarPenna Blue Cheese Stuffed Olives jarPenna Cocktail Onions jar

3. The pizza night basket, $27.70

Garlic Chili Oil, Roasted Garlic Paste and Calabrese Olives. Add a frozen pizza crust or a bag of flour and a pizza stone.

Penna Garlic Chili Oil jarPenna Roasted Garlic Paste jarPenna Calabrese Olives jar

4. The spicy snack basket, $41.60

Chuck Wagon Candy, Sweet Hots, Spicy Green Beans and Atomic Mushroom. This one is for the person who puts hot sauce on everything.

Penna Chuck Wagon Candy jarPenna Sweet Hots jarPenna Spicy Green Beans jarPenna Atomic Mushroom jar

5. The sandwich basket, $26.70

Muffaletta Spread, Dill Pickled Chips and Cornichons Pickles. Add a loaf of good bread.

Penna Muffaletta Spread jarPenna Dill Pickled Chips jarPenna Cornichons Pickles jar

6. The kitchen basket, $38.90

Aged Balsamic Vinegar, Blood Orange Infused Olive Oil and Preserved Whole Meyer Lemons. A good one for the person who cooks and already owns every gadget.

Penna Aged Balsamic Vinegar bottlePenna Blood Orange Infused Olive Oil bottlePenna Preserved Whole Meyer Lemons jar

Three white elephant picks

White elephant gifts need to be cheap, easy to wrap and worth fighting over. These three are all under $12.

Penna Atomic Mushroom jarPenna Frogs Balls jarPenna Chuck Wagon Candy jar

Want to skip the building?

The Christmas Holiday Party Box is twelve jars already chosen and packed, with the 10% off applied.

Quick answers

How much does a basket cost?

The six baskets above run from $26.70 to $41.60, plus whatever you spend on the basket and extras.

Is there free shipping?

Retail orders over $90 ship free, so a single basket will not reach that. Order several together to get there.

Do I get a discount for buying a lot of jars?

Yes. We take 10% off orders of 12 or more jars.

What is a good white elephant gift?

Atomic Mushroom, Frogs Balls and Chuck Wagon Candy are all under $12 and easy to wrap.

Any allergy notes?

Tapenade contains anchovies and cheese stuffed olives contain dairy. Check the label on each jar.